The best toaster of any size I have ever had! Whether it was toast, bagel or English muffin, it was perfect every time. The added bonus was that it didn’t take up much space on the counter.
I was hesitant to purchase a plastic toaster after my steel version that lasted 20 years. However, this little machine has been working great. Light and consistent; I'm very happy with the choice.
I like well toasted toast, not burned, but crispy. On the highest setting, my toast comes out at a medium level of toasted at best (sometimes more medium-low). For having 7 setting levels, I find this pretty shocking. Even more so since this was a Wirecutter recommendation. I'm very disappointed and wish I had purchased a different toaster. What are the other 6 settings even for?
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Response from cuisinart.comBy Cuisinart, June 9, 2026
We’re sorry to hear the toaster isn’t delivering your preferred level of browning and understand how frustrating that can be. For best results, we recommend trying a longer toasting cycle on a mid-to-high setting, ensuring slices are centered in the slots, and checking that the unit is plugged into a dedicated outlet, as power variations can affect performance. If you continue to experience inconsistent browning, please contact our Consumer Assistance Center at 1-800-726-0190 and reference ticket #8901009799 so we can further assist you. Thank you for your feedback—it helps us improve future models.