Customer reviews from Fellow
Fellow - Carter Wide Mug made of 18/8 stainless steel, with a BPA-free plastic lid, & inner ceramic coating, 16oz - Matte Black
Average customer rating
4.5
(432 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 432 reviews
5 Stars
316
4 Stars
54
3 Stars
33
2 Stars
16
1 Star
13
86%of customers recommend this product.
(
81 out of
94)
Customer Reviews for Fellow - Carter Wide Mug made of 18/8 stainless steel, with a BPA-free plastic lid, & inner ceramic coating, 16oz - Matte Black
Customer Rating
5
Repeat buyer
on January 29, 2025
Posted by: Kath
This is my second Fellow. Yep, they are that great. The warm pink is an awesome, soft, almost luminous color, much prettier than the pics.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
5
Mug
on February 12, 2025
Posted by: Rennie
I love my mug. Keeps my coffee nice and cold. It would be nice to have a carry handle like the other mugs I purchased. 😊
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
5
Exceeds Expectations Once Again
on April 2, 2025
Posted by: iwilli
I've been a Fellow guy since the first Atmos canisters rolled out, love their product line. This is my third Carter mug, I've been through two of the standard size 12oz, and loved them both. This time I wanted to try the wider stouter wide version and so far I've loved it. Especially love the conspiracy club option haha. Great product as always.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
5
If you love coffee
on August 13, 2025
Posted by: JJ1103
I love my Carter Wide Mug! I've been drinking my morning coffee from a regular tumbler, and I've always hated how my coffee tasted like metal. I was searching for the best tumbler for coffee and I found Fellow Carter Mug. I'm so happy that I found this! I usually drink lungo, so I went with the 12 oz. I was torn between the Move Mug and the Wide Mug, but I chose the Wide because it’s easier to clean since coffee stains easily. It also perfectly fits my Nespresso original line machine. It would’ve been even better if it fit in my car’s cup holder, but that’s not a big deal for me.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
5
Great for use at home
on September 4, 2025
Posted by: kaenhu
Initially, I thought I would never buy this product because it does not fit in the cupholder in my car. Why would I buy a mug that does not fit in my car? But one Black Friday, I impulsively put a sale one in my cart and now I drink from it every day. It is a nice “at home” mug, keeps my coffee warm for a lot longer than a regular mug, and if I want to leave my coffee for a little longer, I can put the lid on and it really keeps it warm. I like that the wide part makes it more like a cup you’d use at home.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
5
Bullseye, Fellow!
on September 19, 2025
Posted by: KD_TN
I have used this for a couple of weeks now, and it makes me so happy. I do not like drinking lukewarm coffee, and I despise a stainless steel travel mug (so much delicious coffee flavor gets lost). I love to make a good cup from my Aeropress and had read to purchase the Wide over the Move. I’m so glad I did! The Wide just barely accommodates my Aeropress base with hardly any wiggle room—it’s tricky removing the Aeropress—so I know the Move would have disappointed me there. But the Wide gives me the best of both worlds: a delicious Aeropress-prepared cup, plus the full flavor and perfect heat I love. Fellow hit a bullseye here!
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
3
Permanent bad taste
on October 13, 2023
Posted by: BadgerBrews
Pros:
* very sturdy
* leak proof
* good insulation
* very sturdy
* leak proof
* good insulation
Cons:
* soaks up bad flavors
* ruins the taste of my light roast coffee
* interior stains easily
* soaks up bad flavors
* ruins the taste of my light roast coffee
* interior stains easily
I really wanted to love this mug. I even bought two! And it was fine for a darker roast, before I learned how to brew a subtle tea-like light brew. But it absolutely ruins the delicate taste of my coffee. Taste was the whole reason I bought this!
Also if you put anything other than coffee in this, you'll never get the taste out. I've washed it dozens of times, but I can't get the floral taste of a cold-brew oolong tea out of it. Yuck! My coffee tastes like flowers now. The mug is ruined after putting cold tea in it once.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow
Customer Rating
4
Get the Carter move with slide lid for hot drinks!
on February 7, 2024
Posted by: Cierra
Verified Purchase:Yes
Aesthetic, and great temperature control. But I wish the wide mug offered the slider top. The screw off spills condensation and coffee every time I take the top off. Get the Carter move instead!
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Fellow