I just want to say that I am over the moon with my new Tuft & Needle mattress! I had a Tempurpedic for 10 years and I felt disappointed from the start. The price point was very high for me at that time but, because I'd suffered from neck pain for years, I thought it would be a worthwhile investment. It was not. Temperature wise I was never comfortable and I still woke up in pain every morning. It also "sucks you in" so it was a chore to get out of the bed (which was a nightmare throughout both of my pregnancies). Anyway, I was ready for a new mattress so I started researching and your description seemed to line up with precisely what I wanted and needed in a mattress.
From day one, with my Tuft & Needle mattress, I have slept through the night (a first for me) and I wake up with no pain. I find this amazing! This has positively affected every area of my life. As I am now well-rested and pain free, I am more positive, I'm more productive at work and home, I'm a more patient parent and I feel happier overall. This is a priceless gift you've given my children and I. On top of all that, your mattress cost 1/3 of the price of what I paid for my Tempurpedic a decade ago.
Haven't had the mattress for even a month yet so can't truly evaluate it for comfort. Do like it a lot so far. Also, loved the ease of purchase, quick delivery, guarantees, and information on web.