Customer reviews from Staples
Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Average customer rating
4.3
(26 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 26 reviews
5 Stars
15
4 Stars
7
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
0
1 Star
2
Customer Reviews for Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Customer Rating
4
Ink Toner review
on June 30, 2026
Posted by: Toner
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Thanks to the Stellar Product Testing Panel for providing me with the Staples Remanufactured HP 58A Toner Cartridge (CF258A). Overall, I was generally pleased with the toner. There were a few inconsistencies with the printing quality but not enough to make me not want to purchase it in the future. Comparing prices, it definitely saves an individual money going this route than buying brand new. Once a document is printed, it practically mirrors a brand new toner for a fraction of the cost. Only downside was a few pages that I printed for work had smudges/print lines, but it wasn’t always the case - only a couple times. The installation process was quick and easy for me so that was a plus. All in all, I would definitely recommend for a friend and would purchase in the future.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
Easy for everyday use
on June 30, 2026
Posted by: Easy
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this toner through the Stellar Panel program I was pleasantly surprised by how easy this toner cartridge was to install. It fit my printer without any issues, and it was recognized immediately. The print quality was crisp with sharp black text and no streaking or smudging. For everyday documents, it performed just as well as the original cartridge, making it a great value. I'd definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a more affordable replacement toner.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Great Toner
on June 29, 2026
Posted by: Jasmine
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This toner was smooth and easy to operate within my HP printer! Great quality, the color was smooth and printed well. Hopefully the longevity is good as well, I have not used it enough to be able to give an update on how long it lasts. Received this as a part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel but Would purchase!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: Kelley C.
Verified Purchase:Yes
This item will not work with our current printer. The printer gives an error message that says "no chip detected"
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Staples Remanufactured Black High Yield Toner Cart
on June 23, 2024
Posted by: SHARON A.
Verified Purchase:Yes
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] A quality product that saves $ & works just like the original. I buy these all the time! Thank you Staples!!!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: V.L.
Verified Purchase:Yes
Exellent service great produc unbeatable price. Thank you !!t
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: CHELMSFORD PRIMARY CARE D.
Verified Purchase:Yes
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Did not work. Got 2 toners and each one did not work. The HP printer showed an error message about the memory/chip.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: DAVID C.
Verified Purchase:Yes
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] So far so good. While the Mfg. product indicated ~10K pages on high yield toner the staples did not state the number pages but it does appear to be about the same. Third time using the staples brand and will continue for the savings.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples