Customer reviews from Staples
Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Average customer rating
4.3
(26 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 26 reviews
5 Stars
15
4 Stars
7
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
0
1 Star
2
Customer Reviews for Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Customer Rating
5
Great Printing
on August 5, 2026
Posted by: Alexis
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this printer toner cartridge through the stellar product testing panel. And might I say, I never thought a toner cartridge would have me so excited!
The install was easy, and the print job was phenomenal. I used this toner cartridge to print out babies birth announcements. The quality of the ink was perfect and deep in color. Will absolutely be buying these in the future!
By Cartridge Support, August 5, 2026
Dear Alexis Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review- this made our day! We value our customers’ feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to please email us at Support@cartridge-support.com or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Great Toner
on July 21, 2026
Posted by: Mike22
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Normally don’t purchase Store brand toners but this one was better than I expected great quality! Received this as part of a testing panel.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
Great print quality
on July 5, 2026
Posted by: Bnana
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The performance of this toner cartridge was great considering the print job I tasked. I have not done a high print job yet but so far it is efficient for normal sized print jobs. While initially I thought installing this cartridge would be complicated it was actually pretty simple and a quick process.
The print quality was great. The pictures were clear and free of smudges. They always give a crisp look.
In my opinion I loved the print quality and the efficiency. Every time I printed it came quickly and clear. I would certainly recommend this product to anyone in the market. I received the product through the Stellar Product Testing Panel!
The print quality was great. The pictures were clear and free of smudges. They always give a crisp look.
In my opinion I loved the print quality and the efficiency. Every time I printed it came quickly and clear. I would certainly recommend this product to anyone in the market. I received the product through the Stellar Product Testing Panel!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
Good quality
on July 4, 2026
Posted by: Mili
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this from the Stellar Product Testing Panel. The Staples remanufactured toner catridge was difficult to install first and my printer gave error message but thanks to Staples manual user guide which was include in toner catridge box , I was able to install it. The print quality was dark, sharp and consistent. I appreciate that the catridge is lower cost compare to original brand. The toner catridge is going good so far without any fading or streaks on the paper. I would definitely recommend it to my friends as a budget friendly alternate.
By Cartridge Support, July 8, 2026
Dear Milli Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review- this made our day! We value our customers’ feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to please email us at Support@cartridge-support.com or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
CF258A
on July 4, 2026
Posted by: MamaMimi
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product as part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel. It’s efficient and works well. The installation was simple, though I had to clean my printer a bit for better results. After that, everything was good.
By Cartridge Support, July 8, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review- this made our day! We value our customers’ feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to please email us at Support@cartridge-support.com or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Love it
on July 3, 2026
Posted by: emma
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Absolutely. Here’s one that sounds more like a real customer than a polished marketing review:
I received this product through the Stellar Product Testing Panel. I wasn’t sure what to expect since it was a remanufactured cartridge, but it worked really well. It was easy to install, and my printer recognized it right away. The print quality has been clear and consistent with no streaks or faded spots. I’ve used it for work documents and everyday printing, and everything has come out looking great. Overall, I’m happy with how it’s performed and would definitely recommend it if you’re looking for a reliable toner cartridge. I highly recommend.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
3
Staples Printer Ink
on July 3, 2026
Posted by: StaplesPrinterInn
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I got this product as I have tried many levels of Ink and quality for my printer. I was impressed with the quality of this ink I got sent from Stellar Panel. I think it could be slightly improved upon as sometimes it was not as precise and vibrant as expected. Other than that for the cost it is a great option for those not printing at the level of a business.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Works great
on July 3, 2026
Posted by: Kmayer
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve had a printer just sitting in the corner of my office for months without use and I am so happy that the Stellar Panel sent me a Staples remanufactured HP 58A Toner cartridge. Ink is expensive! This toner works great! The print is bold and everything you would expect from a good cartridge of ink. The installation was very easy, although I have done it many times running through lots of ink printing out pictures so I know what to expect now when changing the cartridge. Over all it was very easy to install and the color is bold, so I would definitely recommend it to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples