Customer reviews from Staples
Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Average customer rating
4.3
(26 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 26 reviews
5 Stars
15
4 Stars
7
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
0
1 Star
2
Customer Reviews for Staples - Remanufactured 58A Toner Cartridge Standard Yield Replacement for HP 58A - Black
Customer Rating
5
Great Product
on July 2, 2026
Posted by: Britt
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product through the Stellar Product Testing Panel and it is fantastic! Prints very crisp and clean. Installation was fairly easy. I think the toner quality was good. My papers printed very clear and well colored. There were no faded or splotchy spots. Everything came out great and I’d highly recommend this to friends and family!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Staples Remanufactured HP 58A Toner Cartridge
on July 2, 2026
Posted by: KatW
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this as part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel! What a great score!
Laser toner can be expensive - using remanufactured saves money. Even better - receiving one to use. Who doesn't love 2500+ free pages of black print??
This cartridge was super easy to install - open the printer door, slide out the tray, remove the old and pop in the new. The printer takes a minute to initialize but then it's ready to go.
Quality and performance are on par with regular 'name brand' cartridges. That's what makes it so great!
I sure appreciate this GREAT item!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Superior print quality
on July 2, 2026
Posted by: AlliChicago
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This toner cartridge was very easy to install and only took a couple minutes. Overall the performance is just as good or better than a new product. I liked using the remanufactured toner due to environmental reasons. This toner created beautiful clear print outs. I would recommend this for teachers, families and others printing at home or for projects.
I was given this to try as part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
Go Green Printer ink
on July 1, 2026
Posted by: Mwik
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] First of all I want to say hey GO GREEN!!! That’s so awesome to have refurbished ink to save the earth! I recieved a great chance to test a product from stellar review. We (my family and I) were really were impressed how well the ink worked once it was used from recycled materials. My younger children love to print several pages a day so we were able to print over 150 pgs no problem! There was a minor print discolor in images at the end of the 150 pages. Also installing was fast and simple! Just clicked right into place for a challenged women I am when it comes to technological advancement. I would recommend this product for sure! Thanks stellar!!!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Staples remanufactured Hp58A Toner
on July 1, 2026
Posted by: Carsonann04
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product as part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel in exchange for my honest review. The toner cartridge works great! I have been using it daily and it has not given me any trouble I would never have known it was refurbished!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
As described
on July 1, 2026
Posted by: MrsMom
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] As apart of the stellar panel, I received my staples HP toner cartridge. The one thing I can say about this is consistency. Printing really did become a frustrating battle with streaks and faded ink. Not with this toner. It feels good to have something work as intended. The install was quick and easy and my husband had no complaints. The results came out bright and clear for a good quality print.
By Cartridge Support, July 2, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review- this made our day! We value our customers’ feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to please email us at Support@cartridge-support.com or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
4
Highly recommend Staples HP 58A toner cartridge
on June 30, 2026
Posted by: Emmwhite
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I highly recommend the Staples HP 58A toner cartridge for your home printer! I received this product through the Stellar Product Testing Panel. I printed off around 12 sheets over the span of a couple of days. The cartridge was consistent across all prints. On the second day there were a few areas that could’ve been a bit bolder but overall I was very pleased with it. Installation was a little trickier than I would’ve liked but nothing too hard and I feel like if I purchase one in the future, it won’t be a problem at all. It came with clear instructions, it was just harder for me to navigate a different type of cartridge at first. It took me just a few minutes to install. Thanks for a great product!
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
5
Excellent Performance
on June 30, 2026
Posted by: VivoDavvero
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product as part of the Stellar Product Testing Panel. I was very pleased with the toner cartridge from start to finish. Installation was as expected and easy to complete and start to use. The print quality was crisp and continued throughout use. I use my printer at home for personal use and occasional work purposes and the toner cartridge held up for its intended purposes. I would recommend this toner cartridge to others looking for a similar product!
By Cartridge Support, July 2, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review- this made our day! We value our customers’ feedback. If you ever have questions, feel free to please email us at Support@cartridge-support.com or contact our customer support team at 866.734.6548.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples