Customer reviews from cuisinart.com
Cuisinart - 2 Slice Custom Select Toaster - Stainless Steel
Average customer rating
4.2
(509 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 509 reviews
5 Stars
296
4 Stars
108
3 Stars
47
2 Stars
29
1 Star
29
82%of customers recommend this product.
(
300 out of
368)
Customer Reviews for Cuisinart - 2 Slice Custom Select Toaster - Stainless Steel
Customer Rating
2
Bagel setting toasts both sides
on October 31, 2025
Posted by: ishepperd
Gender:Male
On every toaster I've ever used, the bagel setting is used to toast only one side of the bread. On this model, it still toasts both sides but adds a bit of extra time. That seems crazy to me. I can add extra time myself by adjusting the dial. I verified this in the instructions. "The bagel feature adds extra time to the toasting cycle to allow for thicker breads." I specifically looked for a toaster with a bagel function to toast only one side. It wasn't until I started using this Cuisinart that I discovered it doesn't behave that way.
Also, it doesn't include a crumb tray. You must turn it upside down and shake it. At this price point would expect a crumb tray.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: CajunWeaver
from Louisiana
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
I "test drove" several brands of toasters before settling on this Cuisinart. Toasting should not be difficult, really, but I found many poor toasters on the market. I have been pleased with this toaster. It is consistent in its toasting (not suddenly burning the toast even though the darkness level had not changed) and does bagels nicely/ I would have given it the 5th star if the slots were a bit wider to fit bagels better.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Cuisguy
from NC
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
Happy with it so far. Had it for a few months now. Slots are extra wide which is good for bagels but a bit short for longer bread which is the only draw back. It also allows for you to cancel the cycle
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Joe B.
from Williamsville, NY
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
We bought our new Cuisinart toaster for our new kitchen. It looks beautiful and we love it’s features. Far cry from our old one.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Kim23
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
I bought this a month ago. It's so easy to use. I love that it has different toasting settings like bagels, bread, waffles and pastry. I've used all the cycles on it and everything comes out perfect everytime. I also like the cancel button that's a great feature. Some toasters don't have that feature you have to lift the handle up I never did like that because that's how it breaks. But with the cancel button makes it easier and I don't have to worry about lifting the handle up to get my toast or what ever I'm toasting. Cusinart is my favorite brand, THEIR products are a little expensive but it's well worth it in the long run. It will last a long time.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Val’s sweets
Verified Purchase:Yes
Great settings, perfect toast, bagel, frozen breakfast items.
Nice to push down ONCE and done just the way you like it !
Nice to push down ONCE and done just the way you like it !
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: KatyP7
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
Lever broke off while pushing down on it during the 3rd ever use.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Ipez
from Michigan
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
Slow to toast and uneven single slice browning. Uneven cooking.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com