Customer reviews from cuisinart.com
Cuisinart - 2 Slice Custom Select Toaster - Stainless Steel
Average customer rating
4.2
(510 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 510 reviews
5 Stars
296
4 Stars
108
3 Stars
47
2 Stars
30
1 Star
29
81%of customers recommend this product.
(
300 out of
369)
Customer Reviews for Cuisinart - 2 Slice Custom Select Toaster - Stainless Steel
Customer Rating
2
on January 10, 2026
Posted by: Margaret Howard
Gender:Female
I bought this toaster about a 2 wks ago n im kinda disappointed because I put in one slice n on one side it toasts just fine n the other side burns it i dont have it turned up high. I mean it wasn’t a cheap toaster ..
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Response from cuisinart.comBy Cuisinart, January 13, 2026
We’re sorry to hear about the uneven toasting you experienced. This can sometimes happen if the toaster is on an uneven surface or if the bread slices vary in thickness, so adjusting placement or slice size may help achieve more even results. For further guidance, our Consumer Service team is happy to assist at 1-800-726-0190.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Monroe Mom
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
I had been without a toaster for several years and used my toaster oven without toaster results. I finally broke down and purchased this toaster and am very pleased with the toast and glad I made the decision to purchase this toaster.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Deborah E.
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
I love my Cuisinart toaster. This is my second and my first one lasted for over 25 years. This is a pricier toaster. The quality sometimes beats buying cheap.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Cody Boy
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
Terrific Toaster....Well Built & Looks Good on the counter
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Dennisriv
Verified Purchase:Yes
Very good product once you realize how to use it. The directions or lack there of make it difficult but once figured out, it does a really nice job.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Customer Rating
2
Bagel setting toasts both sides
on October 31, 2025
Posted by: ishepperd
Gender:Male
On every toaster I've ever used, the bagel setting is used to toast only one side of the bread. On this model, it still toasts both sides but adds a bit of extra time. That seems crazy to me. I can add extra time myself by adjusting the dial. I verified this in the instructions. "The bagel feature adds extra time to the toasting cycle to allow for thicker breads." I specifically looked for a toaster with a bagel function to toast only one side. It wasn't until I started using this Cuisinart that I discovered it doesn't behave that way.
Also, it doesn't include a crumb tray. You must turn it upside down and shake it. At this price point would expect a crumb tray.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Customer Rating
3
Features
on October 18, 2025
Posted by: Watti
Gender:Female
The roaster leaver is plastic and broke off and is difficult to use
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com
Posted by: Jltk
Gender:Female
Verified Purchase:Yes
Toasts unevenly!!! Significant portions are left completely untoasted on both sides too
Exceedingly light in weight, not much to it. No heft to stabilize it
Exceedingly light in weight, not much to it. No heft to stabilize it
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting cuisinart.com