For the price this is one of the best chairs I've bought. It is a bit larger than the chair it is replacing (that's a positive!) and is VERY comfortable. Granted it doesn't get a lot of use... this is for a desk in a sitting room that doesn't get a lot of "sitting"... but when it DOES get used it's quite comfortable.
It is a very nice chair. However putting it together was more challenging than I thought it would be. I think the instructions on how to assemble the arms should be made clearer. For example does left mean from rear or front of seat.
The chair this replaced served me nearly 20yrs and cost me much less money. Even though this McAllum Manager Chair is more comfortable and has the strongest plastic base I've seen it clearly is not built to last that long - the plywood seat and arm rest mounts are weak. Also the supplied casters will destroy any floor surface you put it on so a chair mat or upgraded casters will be necessary. I've seen worse. Buy it when it is steeply discounted and it will be a very nice purchase.
I don’t have any comments but to say that I was surprised that there is a two week return policy. This was bought as a Christmas present. So if something is wrong with it I can’t return it. I had to purchase a warranty agreement just in case at an additional cost.
I like this chair right out of the box but I don't love it. At least not yet. A fifth star will depend upon how it wears in. Right now the cushioning is very firm and the leather is very slippery. I've leaned forward and nearly slid off of it.