I tried out every chair on display at my local Staples (about 30). This chair won hands down for comfort. I've only had if for 2 weeks so can't report on long-term use but it feels solid and gives good back and neck support.
The chair is heavy and you can tell it’s good quality. It’s very comfortable and I like the simple look of it. It was kind of hard to put together the top and bottom halves but it was worth it.