If you're not already aware, WE ARE THE FALLEN is comprised of members of Evanescence from the " Fallen" cd. This album is well written and produced. The band is tight. They've gone to great lengths to groom Carly Smithson to replace Amy Lee. She's even changed her appearance to mirror her. She does a credible job on vocals. Carly sounds good, but doesn't have the depth or range of Amy. I like this cd a lot BUT, it would have been even better if they'd patched up their differences and recorded these songs w/Amy Lee. Even so, I'd recommend this disc to Evanescence fans.
What's great about it: As good as any Evanescence cd
What's not so great: It could have been even better
I say nice comeback 'cause it's been awhile. Godsmack isn't an album-a-year band, but this was worth the wait. I think this cd should do for Godsmack what Death Magnetic did for Metallica. It should please longtime fans and certainly attract new ones. Check it out and enjoy!
I like this disc a lot. I think it's a nice follow-up to their debut cd. Their sound is more mature and diverse. There's a great mix of songwriting. The songs that rock still have the edge of their first disc. The slower songs contribute balance. And for what it's worth: I saw Flyleaf in concert recently and they're awesome! Buy this cd, you won't be disappointed.