I was blown away by these movies when they came out over a decade ago, and the extended editions actually improve upon already incredible films. I watch these at least once a year. As perfect a trilogy as there is.
My Best Buy number: 0550473743
What's great about it: As great of a tolkien adaptation as can be.
What's not so great: Peter Jackson took a few liberties with storyline that were not neccessary.
I was very pleased with this movie. I'm a huge Evil Dead fan, and this reminded me a lot of the second and third intallments. I definitely would recommend this.