Most movies of this one's time (even the historical films) seems off with the acting or the accuracy, whether original or based on something else. This one, on the other hand, seemed to get it right. The storyline may seem overused if you've seen every other movie like it before watching this one, if so, this one pioneered the story style better. And not only the story itself, but the acting truly had substance in each character, whether an important character or an extra or even a bit character (and there's truckloads of them in many scenes, no shortage of volunteers). I was surprised to see, for a movie from the 50's, a lot of borderline graphic deaths and some skimpy wear, yet I suppose it was to keep it as realistic as possible while pushing the envelope for the rating system of that time. The major characters that change, personality-wise, take an appropriate enough time doing so while those that don't change don't feel forced in their acting. In fact, the man playing as Nero felt perfect for a psychotic emperor who's full of himself. The locations feel perfectly scaled for the areas they're portraying without a hitch holding the authenticity back, including the chariot races and battles. The historical scenes of Christian persecution, while intense, do feel historically spot on from the emotions people felt to aftermath effects and the shock of Romans to the Christians singing before their deaths. There are not many extras available, just a couple trailers for the movie and a rather lengthy feature on the history of the movie and other historical movies based on Biblical themes and how they became important for the enrichment of cinema. When I was nervous to watch this movie (I'm not normally into movie before the 80's), that special feature, before it was even a quarter way through, convinced me to watch the movie, and I'm really glad I did.
What's great about it: Historically accurate, superb acting, perfect settings, unafraid of the faith and depictions of persuctions
What's not so great: There's supposed to be something not great about this movie?