Customer Reviews for Garmin - fnix 9 Pro - AMOLED GPS Smartwatch 51 mm Titanium - Graphite/Black Silicone Band - (2026)
Customer Rating
5
The Great Debate
on October 4, 2026
Posted by: 2WheelsGood
Pretty much every year I buy both an Apple Watch and a Garmin Fenix to see which is the best blend of smartwatch and fitness tracker. Every year so far the Apple Watch is the one that gets returned. For sure if you’re in the Apple ecosystem, the Apple Watch has some compelling features. But if you’re like me who falls in the gap between smartwatch and fitness watch, the Fenix keeps winning. Also, since I have an Edge 1050, an HRM600, and a Garmin scale, the Garmin Connect ecosystem is also equally important to me.
Anyway, the new 9 Pro is a beautiful step up from my 8 Pro. Not a necessary upgrade by any means, but the titanium case alone makes it worth it.
I've been an Apple Watch user for a long time, and it was fine. Then as I started getting more active, I wanted more. Even simple stuff like exporting a GPX was not possible. I decided to go with the Fenix, and it is amazing. It's large, but surprisingly lightweight. The battery life has blown me away. Before I was lucky if I could go two days, now I'm going weeks between charges. The built in flashlight is amazing, I use it all of the time. The Garmin app doesn't have the same Apple polish, but I love all of the information they cram into it and the insights are surprisingly good. I could go on about all of the features, but I'm very happy I replaced my Apple Watch Ultra with this Garmin.
Really disappointed for an unreliable device (after using fenix 6 for 5 years with success). Returned to seller after 3 weeks. First 2 weeks continuously updating: it used to display 4-6 minutes, it used to take 15-25 min each. A couple of times it suddenly reset. ECG was initially unstable. Advanced interface with Meta is not working yet (Meta advanced interface works with fenix 7 and 8, not with 9). After about 3 weeks the display suddenly became dark (forever) while navigating a bike trip in Moab, UT (thanks to my friend with another device for finding the way home). No Display, but It was still "working" (and sometimes beeping) passing heart rate and steps, but battery lasted 12 hours. I lost my data and memories for the trip and I barely got data (from PC connection) for half of the course. I contacted Garmin support, and I just got standard advice I already tried (push the button for 30/40/60 seconds and no result). No commercial excuses. Returned for refund. Maybe it was too new, maybe I could consider a similar device in the future when this model (or a future one) will be fully working for sure.
I took my Omega Sea Master off and put my 51mm Fenix 9 Pro on. At first I thought I had made a big mistake. The watch looked huge even though I have a large wrist.
After a few days I was hooked. After 15 days I still have 15 days left on my first charge. Im use to the size and the walking, weather, stock market, heart, and other features are great.
I absolutely love this watch. I can believe I only use a fraction of the features but it’s perfect for what I need. I moved from Apple Watch Ultra and one thing that is so good is the battery life.
I love the Garmin products and am looking for a crossover model to be able to change.
So far it's been good for battery life. Working on getting used to all the different settings and features. I would have liked different options for bands. My wrist is a little bigger than the band that came with it.