I ordered these for others in the office and actually have commercial carpet. These seem to work okay with that carpet. I have an older version of the same mat and it still doesn't roll as well as expected so I was pleasantly surprised that these roll so well. But they do seem a little thin.
Have had this mat for less than one week & it has already slid on the carpet and has bent. I've tried to manipulate the vinyl but to no avail. Also there are wheel indentations in the vinyl. I thought the last mat I had was terrible this one is even worse. The first mat I had lasted more than 10 years. I will be happy if this one lasts a year.