Thank you for sharing your thoughts on the Apple Watch. We understand that retaining value for trade-ins is an important consideration when upgrading devices. Apple Watch Titanium users may experience varying trade-in values due to factors such as model demand, condition, and market trends. While trade-in values can fluctuate, our goal is to offer quality, durable products that deliver long-term functionality and an exceptional user experience. We appreciate your input as it helps us for future enhancements, thanks for being part of our AT&T family.