I have only used this Griddle twice since I received it, both times have been excellent results. I am still learning how to properly use the griddle and how to clean and keep the seasoning in tact. The only criticism I have is: There are no printed instructions to reference. Nothing to tell me to visit Weber website (or others) to help me learn how to season and keep the griddle clean.
The griddle is a great add on by Weber for its grilles. At first I was contemplating another brand but this was less expensive and now I dont have two grilles. It has exceeded my expectations. It holds heat far better on windy days, the food tastes great, clean up is much easier. Highly recommend
The griddle insert works great but I have to leave the grills on because the griddle is a tad too small for my older model Weber grill. Weber told me up front that that would be the case. It griddles fine and cleanup is easy.