Customer reviews from weber.com
Weber - Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert for the 4-Burner Genesis 2016+ - Black
Average customer rating
4.7
(283 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 283 reviews
5 Stars
241
4 Stars
24
3 Stars
7
2 Stars
3
1 Star
8
91%of customers recommend this product.
(
211 out of
231)
Customer Reviews for Weber - Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert for the 4-Burner Genesis 2016+ - Black
Posted by: Enrique DJ
from Cicero il
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
very happy with this product. good material quality.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Posted by: Smoothtalka
from California
Gender:Male
Verified Purchase:Yes
More than happy! Griddle insert works great and fits perfect.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Customer Rating
4
Finally all my cooking needs on one of equip
on September 2, 2023
Posted by: the happy griddled
from Caribou, ME
Gender:Male
Expertise:Intermediate
Verified Purchase:Yes
I have only cooked on it three times but have been pleased with my cooks. I think your request for a review is a little premature and that you need to give someone a little more time to use and evaluate. What i have observed so far is that the heat is consistent across the cooking surface and pretty much follows the dial settings. I would suggest in the future maybe a cleanout cut on the opposite end as one may not use the whole surface and because of the varying drip pan locations depending on model. I think that this is a great offering and you should have done it sooner. Now all my cooking needs are on one piece of equipment thats the best part of the new griddle a more versitle grill.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Posted by: Rz9z58
from Orlando FL
Expertise:Intermediate
Verified Purchase:Yes
I really enjoy the griddle insert! It's easy to install and instantly turns your grill into an out door griddle. No need for 2 grills anymore. Absolutely love this thing!
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Customer Rating
2
Disappointed
on June 9, 2025
Posted by: ltcmike23
from Succasunna, NJ
I was given a griddle insert as a birthday present last year to use on my GS-4. I followed the instructions in the booklet regarding "first time user", "seasoning your griddle" and "caring for your griddle." The griddle is not smooth. It has a lumpy surface in spots and it shows rust. I recently cooked hot dogs which were blackened and had to be wiped off before trying to eat them.
Response from weber.comBy Consumer Care, Weber, June 17, 2025
We appreciate your feedback on the griddle insert and are sorry to hear about your disappointing experience. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we are here to help. Please look for an outreach email from our Care Team soon. Thank you!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Customer Rating
4
3 weeks in and no rust.
on May 19, 2024
Posted by: Stucook
from Cornelius, NC
Seasoned 2 or 3 times front to back. Cooked on it 3 times in about 3 weeks and so far no rust. did a huge breakfast this morning starting with bacon and then hash browns and eggs. gotta learn how to zone cook a little better on it. Only issue so far is that the griddle is not balanced to drain to the rear. I will either have to level it off some way, or possibly use it to my advantage. Grease rolls to the front left corner requiring some maintenance after a cook.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Customer Rating
3
Nice idea. But…
on May 18, 2024
Posted by: Jonny B. Good
from Victor idaho
Does NOT fit older genesis 3 grills. This griddle falls right through and does not lay flat over the burners. I have to use it on top of the grates. Which reduces the heat, and takes longer to cook and does not work as well. It never was mentioned that it’s only for new genesis models.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com
Posted by: Rick J.
from Minnesota
Expertise:Intermediate
Verified Purchase:Yes
Very unhappy. Takes FOREVER to heat up!!!!
Would NOT recommend this at all.
The paperwork says it is pre seasoned yet when you get it, you have to season it???
Very unhappy. Will be replacing it with a competitor griddle.
Would NOT recommend this at all.
The paperwork says it is pre seasoned yet when you get it, you have to season it???
Very unhappy. Will be replacing it with a competitor griddle.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Written by a customer while visiting weber.com