We purchased these filters as replacements for our unit. They work well and last longer than expected, in spite of our multi-pet, family of 5 household!
I feel it is working , I have propane heat and I noticed since I bought the Holmes air purifier that my windows don't get the coating like they did. So I would say they are doing their job
I purchased this air purifier several years ago for my sister's home which has two cats and an grandchild with asthma. Since she began running the unit, she reports that air quaility has improved considerably. This is an older model, but still performs quite well. It is rather noisy when it is on HIGH, but this setting is not often required.
I have been using this product for over a year, it does the job. I suffer dust allergies and this has helped improve the life style at home. I can feel he difference.