I’m realizing it’s a trade-off to have the convenience of the straw and one-hand access. There’s more to clean, and sometimes the straw gets dislodged from its attachment and needs to be repositioned. Plus, the little red rubber piece requires a very strong tug to release it from the cap, and it seems that eventually it will wear out.
I love the capacity and dimensions, the color (lupine) and the handle. I do keep drenching myself if the straw lid is not fully extended, but maybe that is user error! I am not sure if it holds the ice quite as long as my Yeti cup but still cold for a long time.