Customer reviews from Nostalgia
Nostalgia - 2-qt. Digital Ice Cream Maker - Aqua
Average customer rating
4.6
(14 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 14 reviews
5 Stars
11
4 Stars
2
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
0
1 Star
1
Customer Reviews for Nostalgia - 2-qt. Digital Ice Cream Maker - Aqua
Customer Rating
5
Pick your own flavors! Amazing machine!
on July 26, 2026
Posted by: LeiahW
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker freezes so well, and the ice cream turns out wonderfully! Imagine being able to make any ice cream flavor you want!?! This is wonderful, setup is seemless, easy, it’s so light weight and easy to move, the material is nice and thick great quality, and the size fits perfectly on the counter!
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
1
Doesnt get cold enough to freeze
on January 12, 2026
Posted by: bkasee66_6773
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was really excited to claim this nostalgia ice cream maker, finally got to use it to make ice cream, it comes with an instruction manual with a few recipes in it, well I trued the creamy and rich chocolate , , great recipe, but the ice cream maker didn't freeze the mixture , it is however easy to use, and clean, it is preset for 40 min, which the book says 20 to 40 min, u can adjust the time, one of the cons, is its hard to lift the canister out of the unit, when it's full of mixture, they didn't allow for that, lol so bcuz it didn't freeze the mixture I gave it 1 star, I was really disappointed with this
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
5
Portable and easy to use.
on January 3, 2026
Posted by: evaobaayaaasabre_4209
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the fact that it’s not the old fashion ice cream marker. Easy to follow instructions and use. Love that it a portal
Size which does not take space on the counter in the house. Great size for a family of 4. I refuse to buy ice cream from the store when I can make my own.
Size which does not take space on the counter in the house. Great size for a family of 4. I refuse to buy ice cream from the store when I can make my own.
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
5
BETTER THAN STORE BOUGHT!!
on December 20, 2025
Posted by: robing34_5259
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was absolutely thrilled by this product! This ice cream maker was a gift for my daughter for her birthday, and she was able to make her own custard based French Vanilla ice cream that tastes 100% better than anything store bought.
To start the process, we cooked eggs, sugar, and milk to create a custard. Then, we mixed cream and vanilla. Both of these items sat overnight in the fridge while the mixing drum stayed in the freezer overnight. Then, we poured both mixtures into the frozen drum and let it mix for 45 minutes, creating the ice cream. After it was mixed, we removed the drum and poured out ice cream into a container to freeze more solidly.
The machine itself was very quiet. Our mixture created about 1 quart of ice cream and our only suggestion to improve the machine would be some sort of fold out handle to get the drum out cleanly/easily after the ice cream had been mixed.
My daughter loved the process, and the outcome was DELICIOUS. We plan on using this machine every weekend and experimenting with other flavors.
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
4
Easy, Homemade Dessert 🍨
on December 14, 2025
Posted by: angelak197_4643
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I’ve been eager to learn how to make homemade ice cream, so I was thrilled to try this machine out! It’s incredibly easy to use, which is a huge help when experimenting with different recipes (which can be a bit challenging in itself). Here are some key tips I’ve picked up so far: make the base in advance and let it cool completely for hours before freezing the canister. You only need to click a button to get started and then just watch the magic happen. The 2 quart size is perfect giving enough ice cream servings for a family which compact enough to store away when not in use. I wish the machine canister was easier to remove from the frame and pop into the freezer or clean. I can’t wait to keep making more ice cream and refining my recipe!
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
5
Very easy to use and easy to clean.
on December 11, 2025
Posted by: jerryd16_491
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Nostalgia Products stainless steel 2-quart digital ice cream maker is a great product. It is very easy to use, easy to clean, and makes a variety of frozen desserts.
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
5
Great product highly recommend
on December 10, 2025
Posted by: Anonymous
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This this is so great! My kids really enjoyed making their own ice-cream. It tastes delicious and it was easy to set up and use. It is the perfect size to store on a shelf. We will be using this quite often.
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia
Customer Rating
5
Annoying to clean but not bad
on December 4, 2025
Posted by: ayerosey_7231
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This was so exciting to use!! I used it with my little cousins and we all had fun using it. It wasn’t too bad for our first time making ice cream and using this product. Cleaning was a little bit annoying though but the ice cream came out okay! We made a fruity one
Written by a customer while visiting Nostalgia