Customer reviews from Select Brands
Toastmaster - 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster - Silver
Average customer rating
4.9
(34 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 34 reviews
5 Stars
30
4 Stars
4
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
Customer Reviews for Toastmaster - 2 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster - Silver
Customer Rating
5
Great toaster, gets the job done
on September 4, 2026
Posted by: ZainabE
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] We love this toaster! It has stayed shiny even with several months of use and has been very easy to wipe down/clean. It’s worked super well with toast; bagels, toasted strudels, etc. my kids use it all the time themselves to make food. We’re really happy we replaced our old toaster with this one!
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Consistent toaster
on September 4, 2026
Posted by: LindseyG
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this toaster! It has a sleek and nice looking design and gets the job done. An even and consistent toast every time. Would definitely recommend! Easy to clean.
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Easy to use
on August 28, 2026
Posted by: YanaA
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I absolutely love this toaster! It has completely upgraded my breakfast routine. Everything comes out perfectly toasted, crispy on the outside and not too dry. Thanks to this toaster, I can make some of the tastiest and healthiest breakfasts at home with almost no effort. And one of the most important things about it is stainless steel! So no more plastic in my food !
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Quite actually the TOASTMASTER
on August 24, 2026
Posted by: KaielynnM
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The design, color, sleekness and easy use makes this toaster SO worth it. It is super silent when toasting and also comes with a defrost setting which I absolutely LOVE! You can toast two slices at once and it’s really easy to clean and empty the crumb tray.
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
4
Solid, Budget-Friendly Option! ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
on August 22, 2026
Posted by: ShannonB
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received the Toastmaster 2-Slice Toaster and overall, it does a pretty decent job!
Pro tip for first time use: make sure to plug it in and run it on the lowest setting empty first to burn off that initial manufacturing smell. After that burn off cycle, I had no issues at all.
Pro tip for first time use: make sure to plug it in and run it on the lowest setting empty first to burn off that initial manufacturing smell. After that burn off cycle, I had no issues at all.
I love that it has extra-wide slots, which make fitting thicker breads and bagels super easy. It features dedicated Bagel and Defrost settings with a dial that goes all the way up to level 7. When I toasted my bagel, the bottom ended up a bit more toasted than the top, but it still gave it a nice crunch and got the job done! Perfect for quick morning routines.
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Two slice toaster
on August 21, 2026
Posted by: FERNANDOS
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Good toaster overall looks nice heat up quickly and does the jobs. Is very simple to operate is lightweight and easy to clean. Works great for the price
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Perfect Crunch with Every Toast
on August 14, 2026
Posted by: KimberlyS
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Toastmaster 2-Slice toaster is a solid addition to the kitchen with its sleek stainless steel finish. It’s a powerful appliance that consistently delivers a perfectly toasted English Muffin, Bagel or plain ol’ Toast, with a satisfying crunch. The adjustable controls are intuitive, and I found that setting 3 is the sweet spot for excellent results.
While it performs well, keep in mind the exterior can get quite hot to the touch while in use, so it is best to handle with care.
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands
Customer Rating
5
Got me toasted
on August 7, 2026
Posted by: JohnS
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Built solid, nice and shiny looking. Crumb tray seems easy to clean, toasts everything I’ve thrown at it so far. Toast everything nice and even. Multiple settings for how crusty yah want it. 😁
Written by a customer while visiting Select Brands