Customer reviews from Plank+Beam
Plank+Beam - Smythe Stool Counter Height, (24in) - 4 pack - Black
Average customer rating
4.5
(26 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 26 reviews
5 Stars
19
4 Stars
4
3 Stars
1
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
Customer Reviews for Plank+Beam - Smythe Stool Counter Height, (24in) - 4 pack - Black
Customer Rating
2
The counter stool set of
on January 6, 2026
Posted by: Cathrine H.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The counter stool set of 4 came with one wrong leg, so I could only assemble four of the stools. The finish color (walnut)was more gray than in the picture.
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
Simply amazing! Smooth order process,
on December 8, 2025
Posted by: Carolina M.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Simply amazing! Smooth order process, easy to assemble, simple and elegant look, comfortable and functional. Amazing value for price. I got the blonde color. My counter is Oak matte, kind of raw, but it goes well with the blonde of the chairs.
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
So much less expensive than
on November 4, 2025
Posted by: Randi R.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] So much less expensive than other counter stools. Easy to assemble, sturdy and looks great.
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
They are exactly what I
on October 28, 2025
Posted by: Rene B.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] They are exactly what I was looking for. Easy to put together, great color, right size. Perfect!
Response from Plank+BeamBy Kasey Silveira, October 29, 2025
That’s so wonderful to hear! I’m thrilled the pieces are exactly what you were looking for and that everything came together easily. We truly appreciate you choosing us and taking the time to share your experience!
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
4
Almost just right…
on October 10, 2025
Posted by: Kim
I was pleasantly surprised by the sturdiness of these stools. I bought 4. The seat area is large and that makes them comfortable even though we are not large people.
I am only giving 4 stars because on the corners the paint is inconsistent and missing layers. You don’t notice unless you specifically look at the corners. But it’s in plain sight. Also, I have a real walnut table. This “walnut” stain clashes with real walnut. It’s not the right tone at all. I really wish I would have ordered black, as they would have complimented my counter height table better instead of clashing. I put them at my counter.
Would I recommend these? Yes. Be cautious of your color pick. I do absolutely LOVE the metal plate on the foot bar.
Response from Plank+BeamBy Kasey Silveira, October 10, 2025
We’re so glad to hear you love the sturdiness and comfort of your stools. We also appreciate your feedback about the paint and color. A member of our customer service team will be reaching out to see how we can help make this right.
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
I ordered the blonde counter
on September 27, 2025
Posted by: Marian R.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I ordered the blonde counter stool by Smythe and they are beautiful! Everyone loves them - the comfort, quality look, and the brass foot rest. I had ordered 2 other sets and returned them before finding these perfect stools for my kitchen peninsula.
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
Love the set, great price
on September 2, 2025
Posted by: Shawn R.
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Love the set, great price too!!!
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam
Customer Rating
5
Highly recommend!
on August 11, 2025
Posted by: Emma H.
Absolutely love these stools! The blonde color is the perfect neutral, and the seats are comfy for relaxing or dining. Easy to assemble""”all three took about an hour. Highly recommend!
Written by a customer while visiting Plank+Beam