This binder is as good as any. It can withstand the wear and tear of an elementary student and also that of a high school student. My only complaint is that after a month or two of use the clear plastic front usually tears or comes loose from the edges. Overall a good buy.
We bought this binder to replace my son's first one that he began using in September. I would say it held up well since we replaced it not for the D clip but for the plastic cover that he chose to rip off.