Customer reviews from Staples
Staples - Heavy Weight Trading Card Pages, 8.5" x 11", 50/Pack - Clear
Average customer rating
4
(38 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 38 reviews
5 Stars
23
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
4
1 Star
4
Customer Reviews for Staples - Heavy Weight Trading Card Pages, 8.5" x 11", 50/Pack - Clear
Customer Rating
2
Not as advertised
on April 28, 2026
Posted by: Mia H
It says 18 cards per sheet, but I must’ve gotten packs that came out wrong because they’re only one sided, meaning I can only fit 9 cards. They also feel really thin, which I wasn’t expecting..
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: BRIAN
Verified Purchase:Yes
The biggest negative I have is the pocket sizes. The bottom row is so much bigger than the other two it makes no sense. The cards barely fit in the top two rows but there is so much extra room in the bottom row. I can't give more than 3 stars for that reason
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Customer Rating
1
Avoid
on May 21, 2025
Posted by: Tom H.
Product is poor quality cards tear right through the bottom stick with ultra pro page for quality and appearance.
Response from StaplesBy May 26, 2025
Hi Thanks for reaching out to us about this. I'm sorry to hear you're dissatisfied with the Heavy Weight Trading Card Pages. I've received your feedback and have forwarded your comments as a suggestion for future improvement. ^MS
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: MARK G.
Verified Purchase:Yes
Good product to protecting your trading cards unit you send them off for grading.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: A.M.
Verified Purchase:Yes
middle row on every single sheet is too small and the card barely sticks out while the bottom row on them all is too big. forced to not use the 2nd row and just use the top and bottom. waste of money wouldn’t but again unless they fix this issue.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: CLAIRE K.
Verified Purchase:Yes
These pages are a very nice quality. They fit trading cards of all sorts. Baseball basketball and Pokemon.
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: MARVA W.
Verified Purchase:Yes
I ordered these about 6 months ago and was happy with them. I just reordered them a week ago and received a defective batch. The top tier are too short and the cards stick out at the top and the bottom tier is too tall. Planned to return these and placed another order hoping to get a good package. Nope. Same problem plus the outer packaging is all sliced up. Poor quality control. Now I have to return both packages and shop from an online competitor. Sorry Staples you failed big on this one
Written by a customer while visiting Staples
Posted by: WILLIAM C.
from Dayton
Verified Purchase:Yes
Pages are exactly as described
Written by a customer while visiting Staples