Customer reviews from Sharpie
Sharpie - S-Gel Metal Retractable Gel Pen, Medium Point, 4/Pack - Black Ink
Average customer rating
4.8
(73 Reviews)
Rating breakdown 73 reviews
5 Stars
60
4 Stars
10
3 Stars
1
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
96%of customers recommend this product.
(
55 out of
57)
Customer Reviews for Sharpie - S-Gel Metal Retractable Gel Pen, Medium Point, 4/Pack - Black Ink
Customer Rating
5
Durable and sleek
on July 31, 2025
Posted by: haleybo16_6830
Theee pens are hands down the best pens. The metal barrel is so sleek looking and durable. I always struggled with the clip breaking off on other pens but these you would have to forcibly break it off. Although they are initially a little more expensive they will last! Most pen tips break before you use all of the ink, but not this one. The rose gold and black ones are my favorite. I once used one for half a year before needing a new one and I have to write a lot at work. Will forever buy these
Written by a customer while visiting influenster.com
Customer Rating
5
No smudging with this pen
on June 24, 2025
Posted by: katiem1372_5644
This pen is my new favorite to write with. It doesn’t smudge at all, and it’s comfortable to grip whist the ink glides on the paper and looks great!
Written by a customer while visiting influenster.com
Customer Rating
5
Write and flow nicely
on April 12, 2025
Posted by: annisae_7185
My new favorite pens. They write amazing and dry quick. Ink flow is perfect, they are comfy to hold. Packaging is simple and easy to open. Pretty color choices too.
Written by a customer while visiting influenster.com
Customer Rating
2
Decent for a while
on October 30, 2021
Posted by: Trina1292
from Flordia
Gender:Female
I have multiples of these pens and I throughly used to enjoy them. Yes sometimes they skip but now they are leaking. It bleeds through my scrubs. I will not carry on the floor with me anymore.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Response from SharpieBy Sharpie Consumer Care, Writing, November 3, 2021
Hi, Trina. Thanks for sharing your review with Sharpie. Sorry to hear your S-Gel Pens are skipping and leaking. Please give our consumer care team a call at 1-800-346-3278, and we will have these addressed. Let's turn this experience around for you!
Written by a customer while visiting Sharpie
Customer Rating
2
Inconsistent Writing
on October 12, 2021
Posted by: Happysynger
from Greeley, CO
Gender:Male
I bought these thinking they would be great pens for writing letters, taking notes, using for work, etc. and I was very let down. Not even two paragraphs into writing something and the pen would stop writing intermittently, causing my writing to be almost illegible. I bought these because I know Sharpie as a good reliable brand, but I was very unhappy with these pens.
No, I would not recommend this to a friend.
Response from SharpieBy Sharpie Consumer Care, Writing, October 21, 2021
Hi. Thanks for taking the time to share your review on Sharpie S-Gel Pens. We are sorry to hear your gel pens are skipping. Please give our consumer care team a call at 1-800-346-3278, and we will have this addressed. Let's turn this experience around for you!
Written by a customer while visiting Sharpie
Customer Rating
4
Great Pen, but no 0.5 mm in Gunmetal Gray??
on October 8, 2021
Posted by: G$$$
Gender:Male
The title is the only reason for a 4 star rating. I have to install the desired fine tip ink cartage myself. Definitely not the end of the world. However, it would be great to just buy it that way. Love the pen, I just with they offered the metal barrel with a fine point option.
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Sharpie
Customer Rating
5
Love!
on October 15, 2020
Posted by: Kayla
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I work in healthcare and having a good pen to write with is very important. These pens are great. They write really smoothly and are a good weighted pen. The ink is dark and dries quickly so I'm not smudging my documents. I really like these pens and will buy more when I run out of ink.
Written by a customer while visiting Sharpie
Customer Rating
5
Quality pens!
on October 14, 2020
Posted by: mommyjoy35
from Bluefield, WV
Gender:Female
[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm always looking for new, quality pens to use at work and home. I usually go for a good ballpoint, but these gel pens are great! No smearing and smooth writing! I have been using them for over a month now and there's still ink! Great pens!
I would recommend this to a friend!
Written by a customer while visiting Sharpie