so far so good had older chair "Osgood" not sure how old showing wear! saw this on sale for $99 thought I'd give it a look. went to look at it and wasn't sure so waited couple of days and the price went up! {by the way store prices are higher but they price match!} watched and waited for the price to go back down bought the protection plan 3yr {how many things go that long without something!} and so far I like the looks and feel for around $120 with protection happy for now!
During assembly I noticed a small (1/4") cut in the seat covering on the underside of the seat near the front-center of the seat. The assembly instructions were simple and easy to follow. However when attaching the seat back to the seat bottom (Steps #5 and #6) after the arms had been attached to the seat bottom (Step #4) it was difficult to position the seat back between the arms to align the attachment holes of the arms with the seat back. I think it would be better to attach the arms to the seat back first and then attach the arms to the seat bottom. Doing Steps #5 & #6 first and then Step #4 would be easier than the order of steps in the instructions. I have now had the chair for 7 days and have noticed that the padding in the arms has shifted to the outside of the arms and not as supportive to my arms. In all fairness I use the chair around hours a day while doing computer work. Even so I think the other features of the chair like the lumbar support are very good.