My printer is relatively new. I replaced ALL of my cartridges. The only color that is correct is BLACK. I took them out to make sure they were in correctly and they were. Perhaps I got a bad batch? At any rate I am definitely NOT HAPPY.
I always recommend HP products. I have used them for over 20 plus years? I know our oldest child was in high school. I love the XL cartridges. It is nice not to have to change often.