The frame is solid and as long as it holds up and doesn&t fail it probably would deserve a 4 or 5 star rating. Its the top that&s the issue. Paying a premium for a bamboo top and receiving. . well I&m not actually sure what but it isn&t bamboo. Its some kind of laminate with basically nothing in the middle. I was actually shocked it didn&t snap when I attached my mounting arm. It looks okay, but it&s full of extra holes on the bottom and yet I still had to drill new holes to attach it to the frame. Just avoid the dark bamboo unless you&re looking for a laminate desktop that looks like dark bamboo (but isn&t).
The desk has been stable so far, not as wobbly as I thought it might be, though I haven&t tested it at the standing height much yet. The instructions manual included for assembly wasn&t very clear, but the instructions video on Youtube was pretty good. I didn&t know that there are a few (2 I think) nails that don&t have predrilled holes and require an electric drill to put them in. Also there were scratches/chips on the underside of my table top. I didn&t bother replacing it because it was very heavy and hard to get out of the house again to ship out.